A historically evocative editorial feature image for a blog post titled “Thanksgiving 1918: The War Was Over. The Waiting Wasn’t.” Show an American family waiting anxiously at home during Thanksgiving in November 1918, with subtle period details: a modest dining table, Thanksgiving meal, an empty place setting, a folded wartime telegram or letter, and a soft sepia photographic atmosphere. Convey the emotional tension between the end of World War I and the uncertainty of waiting for loved ones to return. No readable text, no modern objects, no graphic violence, historically respectful, cinematic natural window light, landscape composition suitable for a blog featured image.

Friends,

On 11 November 1918, at 11 a.m. Paris time, the guns fell silent on the Western Front. The Allies and Germany had signed an armistice—a ceasefire, not the final peace treaty. That treaty would not be signed until 28 June 1919.

“And this is the end of it. In three hours the war will be over. It seems incredible even as I write it. I suppose I ought to be thrilled and cheering. Instead I am merely apathetic and incredulous … There is some cheering across the river—occasional bursts of it as the news is carried to the advanced lines. For the most part, though, we are in silence … With all is a feeling that it can’t be true. For months we have slept under the guns … We cannot comprehend the stillness.” — Robert Casey, Battery C, 124th Field Artillery Regiment, 33rd Division, November 11, 1918.

The news brought huge celebrations. In New York and cities across the United States, crowds filled the streets. The relief was felt around the world, though joy existed alongside grief for the millions who had died. And some people had already celebrated once: a false report on 7 November sent crowds into the streets before the armistice was actually signed.1

Historic newspaper front page announcing Germany's surrender and the Allied armistice in World War I on 7 November.
Image provided by: Minnesota Historical Society; Saint Paul, MN

But the armistice did not mean everyone could simply go home. Nearly two million Americans were serving overseas, and ships could bring them back only so quickly. The first large troop arrivals began in December. From November 1918 through the end of 1919, the War Department embarked about 2,015,000 personnel for home. The Navy’s transport records count 1,933,156 passengers brought back between the armistice and the end of September 1919.2 Some soldiers assigned to occupation duty in Germany remained in Europe until 1923.3

For many, the wait meant time in camps and staging areas before they could board a ship. The Army kept men occupied with exercise and educational activities, but those were poor substitutes for being home.

Isham Hudson noted in a January 14, 1919, diary entry while located somewhere in western Europe on occupation that “. . . This is a pretty lonesome place. We spend our money just to pass away the time. Some intoxicate themselves to pass away the time, I guess.”

The Atlantic crossing took about a week; ships could be crowded and uncomfortable, especially for wounded men. (history.navy.mil)

A typed military document dated 5 March 1919, issuing special orders for U.S. troops aboard the USS Santa Teresa, with an official stamp at the bottom.
Special Orders (No. 64) extract issued on 5 March 1919 by the Headquarters Embarkation Camp, Base Section No. 1, St. Nazaire, France
Side Note:

Most troops returned in 1919, but the U.S. military presence in Germany continued until 24 January 1923.

For most U.S. Army soldiers, arriving in an American port was a homecoming—but not the end of the process. They generally didn’t step off the ship and head straight home.

Crowd of returning World War I soldiers gathered on the deck of the Mauretania ocean liner in New York, 1918.
The first soldiers returning from Europe arrived aboard the RMS Mauretania on 2 December 1918. Records of the War Department General and Special Staffs

Ships returned to ports including Hoboken and New York, Newport News, Boston, Philadelphia, Baltimore, and Charleston. Hoboken handled the largest share: of 37 divisions arriving between December 1918 and September 1919, 27 landed there. From the docks, soldiers were sent to military camps for medical checks, delousing, paperwork, and final discharge. Their accounts and insurance were settled, and then they could go home.

World War I American soldiers wait at an embarkation camp in Saint-Nazaire, France, beside a building marked “Entrance.”
Vintage photograph shows U.S. Army soldiers of the American Expeditionary Forces (A.E.F.) waiting outside the entrance of a delousing plant at Embarkation Camp No. 1 in Saint-Nazaire, France.4

The wait varied. One state archive’s account says soldiers were often discharged within about three weeks of reaching their mustering-out camp, but some returnees—especially in the early months—were held for several weeks. The Army tried to send men to camps near where they had entered service, though that wasn’t always possible.

Women’s return followed a different story. Army nurses served overseas in hospitals, on hospital trains and aboard transport ships. The Army Nurse Corps reached 21,480 members on Armistice Day, and more than 10,000 nurses had served overseas.5 Some continued caring for troops in Germany after the armistice, so there was no single homecoming date for them either.

That Thanksgiving, 28 November, some American troops were still in Europe. Corporal Edwin Seager wrote from France that the war’s end was what he was most thankful for—but he was worried because his last letter said relatives back home had influenza. Lieutenant William Frye, writing from Belgium, told his sister there were no turkeys nearby and that he and his men would eat what they could find.6

On the home front, food conservation was still part of daily life, but it’s worth being precise: the United States did not have the same kind of broad household ration-card system later associated with World War II. The Food Administration relied heavily on voluntary conservation—encouraging people to save wheat, meat, sugar and fats, and to avoid waste. For Thanksgiving, it recommended simple, home-grown meals and economy with fats, while still listing turkey as one possible centerpiece alongside chicken, pork, rabbit, goose or duck.7

Vintage wartime food conservation poster urging readers to give wheat, meat, sugar, and butter to soldiers and allies.
Propaganda Flyer, Illinois Federal Food Administrator, ca. 1918, Record Group 4, Records of the U.S. Food Administration [USFA], 1917-1920.

So, Thanksgiving 1918 held two truths at once. The fighting had stopped, and Americans had reason to celebrate. But many families were still waiting for someone to come home, worrying about illness, or making do with a simpler holiday meal. Gratitude that year wasn’t just for the end of the war. It was also for the people still far away—and the hope of seeing them again.

Three fantasy book covers displayed on a wooden table in a library setting, featuring 'The Myth and the Monster', 'The Writer and the Librarian', and 'The Witch and the Prophet'.

Footnotes:

  1. “Armistice is signed behind allied armies batle lines at 2 o’clock this afternoon.” 7 November 1918. The Bemidji Daily Pioneer (Bemidji, MN), Image 1. Chronicling America: Historic American Newspapers. ↩︎
  2. The U.S. 1st Division (later the 1st Infantry Division) reached New York on September 6, 1919, and was the last American combat division to come home from France. ↩︎
  3. The War Department’s 2,015,000 figure and the Navy’s 1,933,156 figure use different record series and time windows. ↩︎
  4. From Thomas C. Alston Papers, WWI 66, WWI Papers, Military Collection, State Archives of North Carolina, Raleigh, N.C. ↩︎
  5. On April 6, 1917, when the United States entered World War I, 403 nurses were on active duty, including 170 reservists assigned to 12 Army hospitals in Texas, Arizona, and New Mexico following incidents on the Mexican border. By June 30, 1917, the number had risen to 1,176. A year later, 12,186 nurses—2,000 Regular Army and 10,186 reservists—were serving at 198 locations worldwide. ↩︎
  6. Gravy, peach pie and fancy cookies: Thanksgiving 1918 in letters and diaries | UCLA Library ↩︎
  7. In Freedom’s Name: Food Conservation Efforts During World War I | National Archives ↩︎

Resources:


Post-War: Demobilization. Naval History and Heritage Command. Accessed 13 November 2026.

Full text of Demobilization of Manpower: 1918-19: Bulletin of the United States Bureau of Labor Statistics, No. 784. St. Louis Fed. Accessed 13 November 2026.

North Carolinians and the Occupation of Europe, Part 2. NC DNCR. Accessed 13 November 2026.

Highlights in the History of the Army Nurse Corps. History | AMEDD Center of History & Heritage. Accessed 13 November 2026.

Bring Them Home, Uncle Sam. National Archives Museum. Accessed 13 November 2026

What are your thoughts?

Person with glasses holding a coffee mug that says 'GO AWAY I'M WRITING' in an office setting.

Welcome to Chasing History, where forgotten stories come back to life. Join me to uncover the secrets, mysteries, and discoveries behind the past. Let the chase begin.

Let’s connect

Search by Topic

×